Skip to Content

Navigating Difficult Closing Meetings

Blogs Abdullah Al Mahmun, CIA, CMA Nov 18, 2026

Closing meetings are where reputations are built or damaged. They create trust or break it. They shape how management remembers the auditor long after the report has been issued.

I have seen audit reports accepted within ten minutes, and I have seen months of work nearly collapse in a single closing meeting. Over time, one thing became clear: Successful closing meetings depend on far more than good audit work alone. Facts and findings may start the conversation, but successful closing meetings are often shaped by something deeper.

Here are lessons learned from my experiences.

Never ‘Win’ an Argument

Jefferson Fisher, a trial attorney and communication expert, often points out that when people focus on winning, they lose trust, respect, and the chance to connect. This is particularly true in audit engagements.

I remember a closing meeting where management raised serious objections to an audit report. At first, it seemed they were challenging the observation itself. But after listening carefully, the real issue became clear. The report failed to mention that the control gap originated under previous management, unintentionally making the current leadership appear responsible. Meanwhile, the discussion had shifted toward defending the finding and proving the point.

In internal auditing, the objective is not to win an argument. It is to help management understand the risk and work toward a practical solution. Instead of proving “we are right,” focus on why the issue matters and what could happen if it remains unaddressed.

Surprises Backfire, so Align With Stakeholders Beforehand

Once, after a report came out, I received a terse call from the head of the division being audited. “Come to my office within an hour.” He hung up before I could answer.

When I arrived, his first question was, “Did you discuss these observations with my manager before drafting the report?” At that moment, I already knew my mistake. “No. He was on a business trip,” I replied.

His response was immediate: “Sit with him now. He has explanations for every point. Please remove all of them.”

After that meeting, most of the observations were still valid and remained unchanged. But that meeting revealed an uncomfortable truth: Avoiding difficult discussions increases the chance of missing important insights from clients. Closing meetings should confirm alignment, not create surprises.

Let Evidence Speak

Evidence is powerful. Without evidence, audit discussions become opinions. In one audit discussion, management argued that supplier contracts were not required and operating without them was normal practice. However, once the company policy clause confirming signed agreements were mandatory was presented, the discussion ended immediately.

With evidence, facts speak on their own.

Show Both Sides of the Coin

Partial truth can be dangerous. An observation that ignores business realities may make auditors appear disconnected from operations or lacking business acumen.

I once reviewed a report highlighting a segregation-of-duties issue in a boutique. One employee was authorizing, recording, and maintaining custody of returned products. Technically, the point was valid. But the boutique had only two employees, and the supervisor was on leave. It was operational necessity, not intentional control bypass.

Without context, the report told only half the story. Understanding operational realities does not weaken audit findings. It strengthens credibility.

Sense the Room

No matter how solid an observation is, success often depends on reading people. Leadership styles, influence, personalities, and past experiences all shape reactions. Some executives react to ratings, others to wording, and sometimes even to the colors used in reports.

I witnessed one influential executive spend nearly 70% of a closing meeting discussing a single observation on budget versus actual sales variance.

He repeatedly asked: “Why is this even an observation? Did audit report this under previous management?” The discussion consumed most of the meeting, while several other valid findings received little attention. The lesson: Auditors should read the room before presenting the report.

What Is Not Owned Is Not Implemented

An observation accepted in a meeting but not owned by management rarely creates change. I remember meeting a senior executive, known for difficult interactions with auditors. Throughout the meeting, he remained quiet while his team spoke. At the end, I asked for his opinion. He looked at me and said, “This is the first time I am not arguing with an auditor.”

Before the meeting, I spent time understanding the division’s priority and challenges. The observations were accepted and later implemented within the agreed timeline. That meeting taught me something important: Acceptance is not success; ownership is. What people own, they protect, and what they protect, they improve.

Closing meetings are rarely won through authority. An audit report may open the conversation, but the closing meeting determines how the story ends.

The views and opinions expressed in this blog are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the official policy or position of The Institute of Internal Auditors (The IIA). The IIA does not guarantee the accuracy or originality of the content, nor should it be considered professional advice or authoritative guidance. The content is provided for informational purposes only.

Abdullah Al Mahmun, CIA, CMA

Abdullah Al Mahmun is internal audit supervisor for Ali Bin Ali based in Doha, Qatar.